Private parties & catering in Valley Cottage, NY
Bring the good stuff to the table.
Catering trays, pizza and Italian favorites for offices, family gatherings, and celebrations big and small.
Catering
For offices, schools, PTAs and every group in between.
Trays made to feed a crowd: pizza, pasta, chicken, salads and more, all made the Pieman way.
Explore catering
Private parties
A cozy spot for your big moments.
Kids birthdays, sports team parties, graduations and more, in our private room or on the patio. You bring the people, we handle the food.
See the spaceGood food makes a good gathering.
From office lunches to birthday parties, we make it easy to bring people together with the same thin-crust pizza and Italian favorites you love.
Made fresh
Everything made in our kitchen in Valley Cottage, every day.
Easy to plan
One short form, and we call you back with options and pricing.
Room for everyone
Trays for any size group, a private room, or the patio.
Catering menu
The tray menu
Full trays serve 12 to 15, half trays 8 to 10. Pickup or delivery, $250 minimum, 4 days notice (2 for smaller orders). Party buffets from $18 a person, pizza parties $25 a person.
Appetizers
| Tray | Full | Half |
|---|---|---|
| Garlic or Loaded Knots | $45 | $30 |
| Wings | $125 | $65 |
| Chicken Tenders | $80 | $45 |
| Popcorn Chicken | $85 | $50 |
| Vodka Rice Balls | $95 | $55 |
| MeatballsMarinara, vodka or fra diavolo | $85 | $50 |
| SlidersServed with pickles. Cheddar cheeseburger, maple brown sugar Nashville hot chicken, or chicken parm | $95 | $55 |
Entrees
| Tray | Full | Half |
|---|---|---|
| Eggplant Parm or Rollatini | $95 | $55 |
| Chicken Parm or Francese | $105 | $55 |
| Grilled Chicken and Broccoli | $95 | $55 |
| Sausage and Peppers | $105 | $60 |
Kids birthdays
Pizza, friends and a room of their own.
Cheese pies for the picky eaters, a table for the presents, and the whole crew in one place. Tell us the date and how many kids, and we'll plan the food around them.
Plan a birthday
Your people. Your kind of party.
Birthdays, showers, office parties, team celebrations. Whatever you're celebrating, we'll make it easy and delicious.
Check availabilityFrequently asked questions
You've got questions. We've got you.
How far ahead should we book?
As soon as you know your date. Weekdays, daytime and Sundays are the easiest to get.
Can we have a lunch party?
Yes. We open at 11 AM every day. Lunch parties work any day of the week.
How many people fit?
The dining room holds about 50. The patio seats 20, or 30 to 50 standing. Tell us your group size and we will tell you which space fits.
How do we hold the date?
Send the form and we will walk you through it when we send your options.
Can we bring a cake?
Just ask in the form and we will let you know.
Can you do gluten-free or dairy-free?
Note any food needs in the form and we will tell you what we can make.
Do you deliver catering?
Pickup or delivery, just ask. Tell us where and when in the form.
What if our headcount changes?
Let us know as soon as it changes and we will adjust.
What guests say
Parties, birthdays and Friday nights
Austen, the owner ... worked closely with me from beginning to end on a surprise 80th birthday party for my Mom. ... I didn't have to worry about anything.
Along w/ the Pie Man’s Austen and Sarah, I hosted my sons graduation party ... My son said it was the best party he’s ever had.
I dropped off balloons and decorations the night before and everything was set up and looking beautiful when we walked in.
... personal pizza for my 3 year and he demolished it!! They cut it in perfect little tiny slices. It was so cute.
If Google allowed 10 stars, I would give it. The pizza was amazing. You can tell the ingredients are fresh.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting. ... Austen and her staff are very friendly and care about the service they provide.
Great food, great drinks, great vibes! Outdoor patio is certainly a plus. ... Pizza is thin crust and delicious
A thin-crust pizza lover’s dream! ... The service was excellent as was the warm welcome by one of the super friendly owners, Austen!
This place is quickly becoming our family go-to! Welcoming staff and delicious across apps, salads and pizza.
High-quality bar pies with high-quality ingredients. The pizza here will not disappoint. ... Everything was out quick and tasted amazing.
... a wonderful restaurant, with a great family atmosphere. ... All the staff are outstanding. ... The outside seating area is so quaint
Best pizza, garlic knots, and Caesar salads!!! We are huge fans. Love the outdoor summery area for nice nights out too.
Let's plan it
Tell us what you're celebrating.
Share a few details and we'll be in touch with options and pricing.
Thank you, . We've got it.
Your inquiry for and guests is in. Here's what happens next:
- We call you back the same day, usually within a few hours, from (845) 664-0519.
- We go over the date, the space and the food, then send options and pricing.
- You pick what fits and we hold your date.
Prefer to talk? Call (845) 664-0519